mmmmmmmm.......*drools* yummy he is so delicious lookin... - WOLFYGRL, MOUNTAIN CITY, TN    She looks horrible. She doesn't know how to carry h... - CORY, MIAMI, FL USA    10 years is a huge age difference... - CHARITY, LA,CALIFORNIA     I think he is a good actor and he always cast into his... - WANOD, THAILNAD    Cute phot... legendary now. two best artist! =)... - TIFFANY, DONETSK, UKRAINE    rob pat is soooooooooooo ugly! [alyor is so much beter ... - IN UR FACE, FORKS    “We need to figure out how to play it all down be... - YO, NO    I totally agree. I have read the books and do apprecia... - EVA, PORTLAND, OR, USA    until you feel the pain and loss of a child dont judge ... - , AUSTRALIA    i think it is great that i'm a celebrity has starte... - REBECCA, HULL    
My EW Login Register My Comments Community
RSS Feeds

Miley Cyrus Nude Scandal: Celebrities Have Their Say

Find out who's thinking what about those Vanity Fair snaps...

Wednesday 07th May 2008

The Miley Cyrus Vanity Fair ‘nude’ scandal quickly took on a life of its own as stars including Madonna, Justin Timberlake and Hilary Duff lined up to weigh in on the controversy.

Is the Hannah Montana starlet a bad role model for her young fans? Or was it all a big fuss over nothing?

This lot came out firmly on the side of Team Miley...

Jamie Lee Curtis
"She is a young girl. She shouldn't have to deal with any of this. I know the integrity of Ms. Leibovitz and the magazine and I know there were people present at the shoot that should have been looking out to make sure that this didn't happen."

Sally Field
"I love Miley Cyrus. My granddaughters are completely and utterly over the moon (with her). I watch Hannah Montana. I think, 'Let it go for God's sake'. It's a beautiful picture."

Rosie O’Donnell
“ I think the double standard is very hypocritical. We are a country  that sells sex to kids on a daily basis. Don’t blame the little girl. If you saw her on the beach, she’d be more nude than she was in that photo.”

Madonna
"It's all too much, make it stop. Leave her alone... She's going to be 16 soon and then 17 and then 18, and then she might show her knees - and then what's gonna happen?"

Justin Timberlake
"Of course they're going to pick (on) a wholesome, American, young female (for) the first sign of anything. Unfortunately, there's a picture of her that's published with her in just a blanket. And that's the photo, that's the catalyst. But that's also the age we live in. People want to take a photo, and that's who you are for a year's time. We've all become victims of that."

The Hills cast
Spencer Pratt - "I didn’t think it was that bad. Supposedly, she’s wearing a top underneath. It’s artistic.”

Heidi Montag -
"I think she’s a young girl in Hollywood, and she’s just having fun. [She]'s exploring herself.”

Lauren Conrad - “I thought she looked beautiful in the pictures. I didn’t find it that inappropriate. (Being in the spotlight) is difficult. It's a lot of pressure on her since she is a role model, but I think she’s doing a good job.”

Whereas this bunch were less taken with her suggestive posing...

Bill O’Reilly
"They (Miley and her father Billy Ray) go into Vanity Fair, which is not her audience at all. He puts her into a situation where she becomes, at 15, a sex symbol. Middle America, they don't like this. Miley is a nice girl (but she made) a bad decision."

Donny Osmond
"That child's not being protected. She's going to regret that years from now. I've lost a little faith in Miley Cyrus - too drastic for my liking. That's being foolish with your career.”

Hilary Duff
“Everyone goes through things and takes their own path. Who am I to judge decisions that she made? People are pushing you to do something, and if you want to do it, that's your choice, you know? It's not what I would choose to do, but if she did then that's fine. That's her choice. And she said she is sorry - she is allowed to be sorry."

Which celebrity has the best view? Whose side are you on? Be sure to leave your comments below.

Poll  Is Miley a bad role model?

Yes

No


By: Harjeet Mander

Photo: WENN

Reader Comments

(10)
| View all
  • I think there are double standards in our society today. What do we expect from our teenagers when they view this kind of behavior in movies, magazines and news. If we adults cannot be better examples how do we expect our children to do good. The photos are a bit much for a 15 yr. old. My daughter is 15 and I would be mortified if I saw her pose like that. Even if it was art or professionalism. Let our children be children. Where has the innocence gone.

    by Elizabeth, Eatonville, WA USA

     1 year, 6 months ago

    [reply]

  • Replies (1)
  • im no big celebrity but well all make mistakes and this is just one of them.what we all need to do is forgive her because we all do bad things and she learned that what she did was wrong.

    by ayla, detroit

     1 year, 6 months ago

    [reply]

  • Sex is sold to all people of all ages in the 21st century - the photo taken is not porn in any way so just leave the poor girl alone. she is only exploring life and everything that is on offer in the 21st century. If people have a problem with the way life is then they should not hold an influence over the youger generations.

    by sum, Australia

     1 year, 6 months ago

    [reply]

  • Personally, I don't see how this is so bad, Miley like most other teens are being exposed to sex almost everyday. When I'm outside, I normally hear about 10 sexual words in the space of half an hour from teenagers and I don't think this would have happened if stuff like this is wasn't in the media all the time.

    by Who Cares, Colchester, United Kingdom

     1 year, 6 months ago

    [reply]

  • I think miley set a VERY BAD role model for her younger fans. I think she is growing up way, way to fast, expecially for her age. If it were me (I know this is kind of harsh but) I would cancle the whoule intire Hannah montana show and fan club!!!, sorry Miley, I'm just being real with you!!!

    by Brooke, Houston,TX

     1 year, 6 months ago

    [reply]

View all 10 comments...

Add Comment

Register now to have your comments approved automatically!



 characters left. [+]

   






Latest Photos

MORE GALLERIES »

Check out Urban News on TaleTela.com

Check out Festival Guide 2009 on Gigwise.com

© 2005-2009 Giant Digital | Terms and Conditions | Privacy | RSS Feeds | Advertising | Job Vacancies | Contact Us